The SEC’s use of the Terraform Labs judgment in the Binance lawsuit sparks debate. Legal expert Bill Morgan questions its relevance, emphasizing the need to examine specific facts. The SEC argues the Terra ruling directly impacts Binance and Coinbase, focusing on the “investment contract” interpretation. As the legal battle unfolds, the court must weigh these perspectives.
The SEC’s recent filing in the lawsuit against Binance, invoking the Terraform Labs judgment, has added a layer of complexity to the legal proceedings. Legal luminary Bill Morgan challenges the SEC’s strategic move, arguing that the Terra ruling might not be a perfect fit for the Binance and Coinbase cases.
Dave Weisberger sheds light on the Terra case, emphasizing its focus on marketing UST, LUNA, and yield through Anchor Protocol by Do Kwon, the co-founder of Terraform Labs. The crux lies in the definition of an investment contract rather than the nature of the tokens. Weisberger’s perspective becomes pivotal in decoding the SEC’s argument and its potential ramifications.
Bill Morgan joins the discourse, aligning with Weisberger’s viewpoint. He suggests that the Terra ruling’s application of the Howey test might be as unique as the Torres decision on Ripple’s sale of XRP. Morgan posits that the Terra judgment may lack broad relevance in the context of the Binance and Coinbase lawsuits. He underscores the importance of recognizing that legal cases often hinge on specific facts.
The SEC leans on the Terra case, contending that the Howey Test’s application by the court is directly pertinent to classifying tokens like UST, LUNA, wLUNA, and MIR as investment contracts and securities. This stance extends to products and services offered by Binance, including BUSD, BNB Vault, and the Simple Earn program. Bill Morgan, however, challenges this extension, asserting that the SEC’s approach may be overreaching.
As the legal tussle unfolds, the court faces the intricate task of weighing the SEC’s reliance on the Terra ruling against Bill Morgan’s skepticism. The outcome will significantly impact the regulatory landscape for digital assets and services offered by major cryptocurrency exchanges.